1By the criterion of the professional skills of the judge are evaluated the professional skills of the judge in terms of legal knowledge and legal reasoning.
2The aspect of the legal knowledge will be assessed with regard to the judges’ ability to render judicial decisions, against indicators like the overall capacity to interpret the law, detect conflicts of law, use general principles of the legal theory and the capacity to analyse the case law.
3The aspect of legal reasoning the judges in rendering judicial decisions will be assessed against indicators like the clearness and comprehensiveness of the decision, a consistent and developed structure of the decision, the quality of analysis and the logical argument.
4The evaluator will assess the judicial capacity without judging over the correctness of the decision or merits of the case while not substituting the interpretation or the logic of the evaluated judge.
EN